The best watercolor paint set for most artists is the Kuretake Gansai Tambi 24 Colors, thanks to its creamy, highly pigmented pans that behave more like artist-grade paint than anything else at this price. For artists who want maximum color range on a budget, the Caliart 128 Colors set delivers variety and portability, while the Artistro Professional 48-Color set stands out for lightfastness and oversized pans that suit daily studio work. The core tradeoff in this category is pigment quality versus color count: massive 168-color sets are tempting, but they often spread a thin paint formula across more pans, while smaller curated sets concentrate their budget into richer pigment loads. Another decision point is format — pocket sets favor field sketching, tube sets favor studio mixing, and all-in-one kits favor convenience over refinement. Keep reading for the full breakdown of all 13 sets and which one fits your workflow.
Get art and craft supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Key Takeaways
- Kuretake Gansai Tambi punched above its price with artist-grade pigment behavior, beating sets with five times the color count because its 24 pans mix cleanly and rewet easily.
- Sets above roughly 100 colors (Caliart, Artecho 168, Smallbudi 168) consistently showed thinner, less saturated formulas — great for hobbyists and color swatching, weaker for serious work needing lightfastness.
- Winsor & Newton’s two Cotman sets proved format matters more than brand: the Pocket Set wins for travel, while the 5ml tube set wins for studio painters who mix large washes.
- Artistro‘s three sets landed in distinct tiers — the Professional 48 with XL pans was the strongest, while the 100-color Deluxe and 50-color travel kit traded pigment quality for versatility.
- All-in-one kits with included brushes and palettes (Smallbudi, Nicpro, the generic 100-color set) are best treated as starter bundles; the included accessories almost always need upgrading within months.
| Artistro Professional Watercolor Paint Set – 48 Vibrant Colors |  | Best Overall | Paint Type: Watercolor pans | Number of Colors: 48 | Lightfastness: ASTM-I | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ARTISTRO Deluxe Watercolor Paint Set with Palette & Brush Pens – 100 Colors |  | Best Value for Color Range | Number of Colors: 100 | Includes: Watercolor pans, brush pens, mixing palette | Case Type: Travel case | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Nicpro Watercolor Paint Set for Adults and Kids, 36 Colors |  | Best Complete Starter Kit | Number of Colors: 36 | Paint Format: 12ml/0.4oz tubes | Includes: 10 brushes, palette, watercolor pad, color wheel, swatch sheet | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Winsor & Newton Cotman Watercolor Paint Set, Sketchers’ Pocket Set |  | Best Compact Pocket Set | Brand: Winsor & Newton | Number of Colors: 12 half pans | Paint Line: Cotman | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Caliart 128 Colors Watercolor Paint Set, Portable Art Supplies Palette Kit |  | Best for Maximum Color Variety | Number of Colors: 128 (72 regular, 40 metallic, 10 pastel, 6 fluorescent) | Paint Type: Solid watercolor, matte and metallic | Total Pieces: 141 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Watercolor Paint Set with 100 Vibrant Colors for Artists of All Levels |  | Best Color Variety for the Price | Number of Colors: 100 | Color Types: Regular, metallic, fluorescent, candy | Includes: 3 watercolor brush pens, 2 paint brushes, art sponge, swatch card | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kuretake Gansai Tambi Watercolor Paint Set, 24 Colors |  | Best Premium Quality | Number of Colors: 24 | Paint Type: Watercolor (opaque, Japanese-style) | Origin: Japan | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ARTISTRO Watercolor Paint Set – Travel Art Kit – 50 Colors |  | Best Balanced Travel Set | Number of Colors: 50 | Paint Type: Watercolor | Includes: Paints, brushes, mixing palette, metal case | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Artecho 48 Colors Watercolor Paint Set with 3 Brushes |  | Best Value for Beginners | Number of Colors: 48 | Paint Type: Watercolor | Included Components: 48 paint pans, 3 brushes | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Artecho 100 Colors Watercolor Paint Set with Metallics |  | Best Complete Starter Bundle | Number of Colors: 100 | Color Types: Classic, metallic, fluorescent, macaron, candy | Includes: Water brush pen, nylon brush, sketching pencil, sharpener, color chart, watercolor paper, sponge | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Smallbudi All-in-One Watercolor Paint Set – 168 Colors with Portable Box |  | Best All-in-One Kit | Paint Colors: 168 | Brushes: 8 synthetic squirrel hair brushes | Watercolor Paper: 25 sheets, cold-pressed | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Winsor & Newton Cotman Watercolor Paint Set, 20 Colors, 5ml Tubes |  | Best Beginner Tube Set | Brand: Winsor & Newton | Paint Type: Watercolor | Number of Colors: 20 | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Artecho 168-Color Watercolor Paint Set with Metallics |  | Best for Specialty Effects | Number of Colors: 168 | Color Types: Classic, Metallic, Pastel, Fluorescent | Includes: Water brush pens, sketching pencil, eraser, sharpener, color chart, watercolor pad, sponge | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| watercolor paint sets for artist | Number of Colors | Includes | Safety Standards |
|---|---|---|---|
| Artistro Professional Watercol | 48 | — | — |
| ARTISTRO Deluxe Watercolor Pai | 100 | Watercolor pans, brush pens, mixing palette | ASTM D-4236, EN71 |
| Nicpro Watercolor Paint Set fo | 36 | 10 brushes, palette, watercolor pad, color wheel, swatch sheet | ASTM D4236, EN71 |
| Winsor & Newton Cotman Waterco | 12 half pans | 12 half pans, pocket brush, integral mixing palette | — |
| Caliart 128 Colors Watercolor | 128 (72 regular, 40 metallic, 10 pastel, 6 fluorescent) | Color chart, eraser, sketch pencil, water brush pens, watercolor brushes | ASTM D-4236 |
| Watercolor Paint Set with 100 | 100 | 3 watercolor brush pens, 2 paint brushes, art sponge, swatch card | ASTM D-4236, EN71 |
| Kuretake Gansai Tambi Watercol | 24 | — | — |
| ARTISTRO Watercolor Paint Set | 50 | Paints, brushes, mixing palette, metal case | ASTM D-4236, EN71 |
| Artecho 48 Colors Watercolor P | 48 | — | — |
| Artecho 100 Colors Watercolor | 100 | Water brush pen, nylon brush, sketching pencil, sharpener, color chart, watercolor paper, sponge | ASTM D-4236 |
| Smallbudi All-in-One Watercolo | — | — | — |
| Winsor & Newton Cotman Waterco | 20 | — | — |
| Artecho 168-Color Watercolor P | 168 | Water brush pens, sketching pencil, eraser, sharpener, color chart, watercolor pad, sponge | ASTM D-4236 |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Artistro Professional Watercolor Paint Set – 48 Vibrant Colors
This set stands out as the most balanced option in the lineup. The 48 XL pans deliver genuine professional-grade pigment behavior, and the ASTM-I lightfastness rating means finished pieces won’t fade the way budget sets like the Caliart 128-color kit often do. Compared with the Caliart, you give up raw color count, but what you get is concentrated, transparent color that lifts and blends predictably — the difference between painting and just applying color. The extra-large pans also outlast the tiny half-pans in the Winsor & Newton Sketchers’ Pocket Set, so heavy painters won’t run dry mid-project. The tradeoff is honest: 48 colors requires more mixing from scratch, and the one-hour dry time demands patience if you layer quickly.
Pros:- ASTM-I lightfastness rating for archival, fade-resistant artwork
- XL pans hold far more paint than standard half-pans
- Strong transparency and tinting strength for layered techniques
- Sturdy travel-friendly case doubles as a working box
Cons:- 48 colors requires more manual color mixing than larger sets
- One-hour dry time slows down fast layering workflows
Best for: Serious hobbyists and professional artists who want pigment quality and lightfastness without paying artisan-brand prices
Not ideal for: Artists who want an exhaustive ready-made palette — 48 colors means mixing your own secondary shades frequently
- Paint Type:Watercolor pans
- Number of Colors:48
- Lightfastness:ASTM-I
- Pan Size:XL
- Included Components:Pans, palette
- Dry Time:1 hour
- Manufacturer:Artistro
Our verdict“The strongest all-around pick for artists who care more about pigment performance than color count.”
ARTISTRO Deluxe Watercolor Paint Set with Palette & Brush Pens – 100 Colors
For buyers who measure a set by its palette breadth, this option delivers 100 high-pigment colors at a price per color that undercuts nearly everything here. The built-in mixing palette and included brush pens make it genuinely ready to paint out of the box — no extra purchases needed, unlike the Nicpro 36-color set where the accessories are more basic. Compared with the Caliart 128-color kit, you lose the metallic and fluorescent gimmicks but get a cleaner, more traditional watercolor range, which most artists will actually use more often. The tradeoff is that pigment load sits a step below the Artistro 48-pan professional set, so demanding artists may find some colors need two passes for full saturation. It’s a quantity-first purchase, and a smart one at that.
Pros:- 100 colors at an excellent price per shade
- Includes brush pens and a built-in mixing palette
- Portable travel case for plein air and commuting artists
- Non-toxic and safe for all skill levels and ages
Cons:- Pigment concentration is a notch below professional-grade sets
- Watercolor-only — no other media included
Best for: Hobbyists and students who want a broad ready-to-use palette and complete accessory bundle at a low cost per color
Not ideal for: Professional artists prioritizing lightfastness and single-pass pigment density over palette size
- Number of Colors:100
- Includes:Watercolor pans, brush pens, mixing palette
- Case Type:Travel case
- Safety Standards:ASTM D-4236, EN71
- Skill Level:All levels
- Manufacturer:Artistro
Our verdict“The smart buy when palette breadth matters more than artisan pigment quality.”
Nicpro Watercolor Paint Set for Adults and Kids, 36 Colors
This is the only set in the batch built as a true all-in-one starter bundle: 36 tubes of paint, 10 brushes, a reusable palette, a 140lb watercolor pad, a color wheel, and swatch sheets. A beginner buying the Winsor & Newton Sketchers’ Pocket Set would still need paper, better brushes, and guidance — the Nicpro includes all of it. Tube paint also teaches mixing fundamentals better than pre-pans, since you control exactly how much paint hits the palette. The compromise is clear against professional options: 36 colors is a limited range, and the bundled brushes are serviceable rather than refined, so artists developing advanced techniques will outgrow them. Still, for a first serious foray into watercolor, nothing here matches the out-of-box completeness.
Pros:- Complete bundle: tubes, 10 brushes, palette, 140lb paper pad, and guides
- Tube format teaches color mixing and control from day one
- Non-toxic and safe for all ages
- Gift-ready packaging that doesn’t require supplementary purchases
Cons:- 36 colors is restrictive for artists with developed palettes
- Included brushes are entry-level and imprecise for detail work
Best for: Beginners and gift-givers who want paints, brushes, paper, and learning guides in one purchase
Not ideal for: Experienced artists — the limited palette and basic brushes will feel like a step backward
- Number of Colors:36
- Paint Format:12ml/0.4oz tubes
- Includes:10 brushes, palette, watercolor pad, color wheel, swatch sheet
- Paper Weight:140lb/300g
- Safety Standards:ASTM D4236, EN71
- Manufacturer:Nicpro
Our verdict“The best first watercolor purchase you can make — everything a beginner needs, nothing they don’t.”
Winsor & Newton Cotman Watercolor Paint Set, Sketchers’ Pocket Set
Nothing else in this lineup competes on sheer portability — at 90 grams with an integral lid palette and a pocket brush, this fits in a jacket pocket. That’s the entire point: where the Artistro 48-pan set is a working studio box, the Cotman Pocket Set is for the artist who sketches on trains, hikes, and café tables. The Cotman pigment quality from Winsor & Newton also outclasses generic budget pans in blending behavior and rewetting, which matters when you’re working small and fast. The compromises are structural, though: 12 fixed half-pans can’t be swapped or expanded, and the tiny pans run out quickly with regular use. Buyers wanting a growable travel system should look at larger sets, but for urban sketching and travel journaling, this is the classic for a reason.
Pros:- True pocket portability at just 90 grams
- Winsor & Newton Cotman paint with reliable transparency and tinting
- Integral mixing palette and pocket brush built into the lid
- Proven, durable design from an established art materials brand
Cons:- Only 12 pre-selected colors with no way to customize the palette
- Small half-pans deplete quickly with frequent use
Best for: Urban sketchers, travelers, and journalers who need a genuine pocket-sized set with heritage-brand paint quality
Not ideal for: Studio painters — 12 fixed colors and miniature pans are impractical for sustained or large-format work
- Brand:Winsor & Newton
- Number of Colors:12 half pans
- Paint Line:Cotman
- Includes:12 half pans, pocket brush, integral mixing palette
- Weight:0.09 kg
- Dry Time:2 hours
- Model Number:0390640
Our verdict“The definitive travel set — buy it for portability and paint quality, not for palette breadth.”
Caliart 128 Colors Watercolor Paint Set, Portable Art Supplies Palette Kit
If the selling point is sheer range, this 128-color kit wins the numbers game outright: 72 regular shades plus 40 metallic, 10 pastel, and 6 fluorescent pans, alongside water brushes, a sketch pencil, and a color chart. Compared with the ARTISTRO 100-color set, the extra value lies in the specialty finishes — metallics and fluorescents that open up card-making, illustration, and craft projects traditional sets can’t touch. But that breadth is also the weakness: the metallic and fluorescent pans behave differently from classic transparent watercolor, so purists working on traditional washes and glazes will find a third of the set rarely used. There are also no individual refills, so favorite colors that run dry mean repurchasing the whole kit. As a creative playground rather than a disciplined studio tool, it makes sense for mixed-media hobbyists.
Pros:- 128 colors including 40 metallic, 10 pastel, and 6 fluorescent pans
- 141 total pieces with water brushes, sketch pencil, and color chart
- Portable, organized box for painting anywhere
- Non-toxic and ASTM D-4236 conformant for family use
Cons:- Metallic and fluorescent pans are less useful for traditional watercolor work
- No individual color refills — depleted favorites force a full repurchase
Best for: Crafters, card-makers, and mixed-media hobbyists who want specialty finishes and a huge palette in one box
Not ideal for: Traditional watercolor purists — metallics and fluorescents sit outside classic transparent technique, and favorites can’t be refilled
- Number of Colors:128 (72 regular, 40 metallic, 10 pastel, 6 fluorescent)
- Paint Type:Solid watercolor, matte and metallic
- Total Pieces:141
- Includes:Color chart, eraser, sketch pencil, water brush pens, watercolor brushes
- Safety Standards:ASTM D-4236
- Recommended Surfaces:Watercolor paper, pads, workbooks, sketchbooks, cards
Our verdict“A variety-first set built for craft and mixed-media exploration rather than disciplined watercolor practice.”
Watercolor Paint Set with 100 Vibrant Colors for Artists of All Levels
Where the Kuretake Gansai Tambi set offers just 24 carefully tuned colors, this set goes the opposite direction: 100 shades spanning regular, metallic, fluorescent, and candy hues for about the same money. That range makes the most sense for illustrators and hobbyists who want unusual accents — the fluorescent and candy tones are genuinely hard to find in budget sets. The included brush pens, sponge, and swatch card mean a beginner can start painting without buying anything else. The tradeoff is depth over breadth: pigment load and blending behavior aren’t documented, so painters chasing smooth gradients or lightfast work will outgrow these pans quickly. Compared with the Artecho 48-color set, you double the palette but get similarly student-grade paint.
Pros:- 100 colors including hard-to-find metallic, fluorescent, and candy shades
- Complete starter kit with brush pens, brushes, sponge, and swatch card
- Slim metal case that slips into a bag for plein air sessions
- ASTM D-4236 and EN71 certified non-toxic
Cons:- No documented lightfastness or pigment information for professional work
- Blending and drying behavior are inconsistent across the specialty shades
- Very shallow case leaves little room to carry extra brushes or paper
Best for: Hobbyists and illustrators who want maximum color variety, including metallics and fluorescents, without buying separate specialty sets
Not ideal for: Artists focused on lightfastness and archival quality — pigment information is thin and these paints are firmly student-grade
- Number of Colors:100
- Color Types:Regular, metallic, fluorescent, candy
- Includes:3 watercolor brush pens, 2 paint brushes, art sponge, swatch card
- Case Dimensions:3.25 x 8 x 1.5 cm
- Material:High-quality pigments, metal case
- Safety Standards:ASTM D-4236, EN71
Our verdict“Buy this if sheer color variety matters more than pigment quality; skip it if you need archival, lightfast watercolors.”
Kuretake Gansai Tambi Watercolor Paint Set, 24 Colors
This is the quality-first pick in a lineup otherwise crowded with quantity-first sets. The Gansai Tambi paints are Japanese-made, more opaque than typical Western watercolors, and dry with a subtle sheen that gives finished pieces a distinct character. The large pans accommodate wide brushes, something the cramped half-pans in the Winsor & Newton Cotman Pocket Set simply can’t do — a real advantage for loose, expressive washes. Where the 100-color budget sets give you breadth with student-grade pigment, Kuretake gives you 24 colors that behave predictably, layer cleanly, and blend smoothly. The honest tradeoff: 24 colors requires more mixing from you, and replacing individual pans costs more over time than rebuying a cheap complete set. This set is better suited to artists who would rather master mixing than own every hue.
Pros:- Professional-grade Japanese pigments with smooth, predictable blending
- Oversized pans work with everything from detail brushes to wide wash brushes
- Distinctive opaque finish with a slight sheen for stylized artwork
- Replaceable individual pans instead of discarding the whole set
Cons:- Only 24 colors, which demands mixing skills for complex palettes
- Replacement pans cost more over time than budget complete sets
- The opaque, sheen finish won’t suit painters wanting traditional transparent watercolor effects
Best for: Intermediate and professional artists who prioritize pigment quality, opacity, and large pans over sheer color count
Not ideal for: Beginners who want a wide ready-made palette — 24 colors means lots of mixing, and replacement pans add cost
- Number of Colors:24
- Paint Type:Watercolor (opaque, Japanese-style)
- Origin:Japan
- Non-Toxic:Yes
- Replaceable Pans:Yes
- Drying Finish:Slight sheen
Our verdict“The clear quality pick if you’d rather have 24 excellent paints than 100 average ones — provided you’re comfortable mixing your own colors.”
ARTISTRO Watercolor Paint Set – Travel Art Kit – 50 Colors
This set lands in the sweet spot between the skinny 24-color Kuretake Gansai Tambi and the sprawling 100-color sets elsewhere in this roundup. Fifty colors is enough to paint almost any subject without mixing gymnastics, yet the whole kit — paints, brushes, and a built-in mixing palette — still fits in a durable metal case you can toss in a backpack. Compared with the Artecho 48-color set, it trades a slightly leaner accessory load for that integrated palette, which matters more when you’re painting outdoors without a studio setup. The paints are blendable and safe for all ages, though they lean transparent: expect to build multiple layers for saturated color, which tests patience on quick sketches. For travel-focused buyers, that tradeoff is reasonable given the tidy footprint.
Pros:- 50 colors balance variety without overwhelming beginners
- Integrated mixing palette means no extra gear for plein air painting
- Durable metal case survives being carried in a bag daily
- Non-toxic and ASTM/EN71 certified for family use
Cons:- Paints are on the transparent side and need multiple layers for vivid results
- No refill system — used-up pans mean replacing the whole set
- Watercolor only, with no metallic or specialty shades
Best for: Traveling artists and students who want a mid-sized palette with an integrated mixing palette in a rugged case
Not ideal for: Painters who want rich, saturated color in one pass — these paints need layering to reach full intensity
- Number of Colors:50
- Paint Type:Watercolor
- Includes:Paints, brushes, mixing palette, metal case
- Safety Standards:ASTM D-4236, EN71
- Portability:Compact metal travel case
- Skill Level:Beginner to experienced
Our verdict“The most sensible middle ground for artists who travel: more colors than Kuretake, less bulk than the 100-color tins.”
Artecho 48 Colors Watercolor Paint Set with 3 Brushes
For a first watercolor set, this Artecho kit gets the basics right without padding the price. The 48-color palette is thoughtfully chosen — unlike the 100-color sets that pad the range with near-duplicates, every pan here earns its slot, so beginners learn to use color deliberately rather than endlessly sampling. It includes three brushes, so a newcomer can paint the moment the box arrives, and the washable, non-toxic pigments make it a low-stakes choice for kids and classrooms. Compared with the ARTISTRO 50-color travel kit, it costs less but skips the built-in mixing palette, so you’ll want a plate or tile on hand. The brushes are serviceable rather than good — anyone who sticks with watercolor will upgrade within months. As a learn-the-medium set, though, that’s an acceptable tradeoff.
Pros:- 48 well-chosen colors with no filler shades
- Everything included to start painting immediately out of the box
- Washable, non-toxic pigments safe for children and classrooms
- Compact, travel-friendly layout at a beginner-friendly price
Cons:- Included brushes are entry-level and shed or lose their point with use
- Some colors need up to 1.5 hours to fully dry, slowing layering work
- No mixing palette or paper included, unlike pricier kits in this roundup
Best for: First-time watercolor painters and parents buying for kids who want a well-rounded, low-cost starter kit
Not ideal for: Artists who already know they’ll stick with watercolor — the basic brushes and student pigments will need replacing quickly
- Number of Colors:48
- Paint Type:Watercolor
- Included Components:48 paint pans, 3 brushes
- Material:Washable, non-toxic pigments
- Dry Time:Approximately 1.5 hours
- Recommended Use:Art, illustration, calligraphy, gifting
- Model Number:ATO-WP4801
Our verdict“The smartest low-risk entry point into watercolor — just budget for better brushes once the hobby sticks.”
Artecho 100 Colors Watercolor Paint Set with Metallics
This is the set for someone who wants everything in one tin: 100 colors plus a water brush pen, nylon brush, sketching pencil, sharpener, color chart, sponge, and actual watercolor paper. Compared with the 100-color set from B0CGX7DFKW, the accessory load here is far more generous — that rival ships brushes and a sponge, while this one effectively delivers a complete painting station. The palette spans classic, metallic, fluorescent, macaron, and candy shades, which suits illustrators, journalers, and card-makers more than traditional landscape painters. The compromises are real: the metallics dry less opaque than the names suggest, the tin is chunkier than genuinely pocketable sets like the Cotman Pocket Set, and you still need to carry water. For gift-giving, though, few sets in this roundup look as impressive straight out of the box.
Pros:- 100 colors spanning classic, metallic, fluorescent, macaron, and candy ranges
- Includes paper, water brush, pencil, sharpener, sponge, and color chart
- Well-organized metal case that works as an attractive gift
- Non-toxic, acid-free, and washable pigments safe for all ages
Cons:- Metallic shades dry patchier and less opaque than expected
- Case is too bulky for genuine pocket or everyday-carry use
- Needs a separate water source, which limits spontaneous outdoor sessions
Best for: Gift buyers and creative hobbyists who want a full painting bundle — paints, brushes, paper, and accessories — in a single presentation-ready tin
Not ideal for: Minimalist travelers — the tin is bulkier than compact pocket sets and metallics underperform if opacity is the goal
- Number of Colors:100
- Color Types:Classic, metallic, fluorescent, macaron, candy
- Includes:Water brush pen, nylon brush, sketching pencil, sharpener, color chart, watercolor paper, sponge
- Safety Standards:ASTM D-4236
- Material:Non-toxic, acid-free, washable
- Case:Portable metal tin
Our verdict“The best all-in-one gift set in this lineup — buy it for the complete package, not for pigment performance.”
Smallbudi All-in-One Watercolor Paint Set – 168 Colors with Portable Box
This option stands out for sheer completeness: 168 colors, eight synthetic squirrel hair brushes, 25 sheets of cold-pressed paper, and a long list of accessories all packed into a lockable metal box with a velvet carry bag. Where the Artecho 168-color set leans heavily on specialty shades, the Smallbudi set invests more in the supporting kit — water brush pens, palette, tape, even a pencil and sharpener — which means a buyer can paint from the box without buying anything else. The tradeoff is portability: this is one of the bulkier sets in the lineup, and next to the Winsor & Newton Cotman pocket-sized options it feels more like a mobile studio than a travel kit. The huge palette can also slow down color-mixing education for someone still learning the fundamentals.
Pros:- 168 colors covering an unusually wide mixing range for the price
- Includes paper, brushes, palette, and drawing accessories — genuinely everything needed to start
- Lockable metal box and velvet bag protect the set in transit
- Non-toxic, easy-blending formula suitable for all ages
Cons:- 168 pans can overwhelm beginners who haven’t learned color mixing yet
- Bulkier than pocket and half-pan alternatives for light travel
Best for: Hobbyists and gift-buyers who want a complete, ready-to-paint studio in one purchase, including paper and tools
Not ideal for: Minimalist travelers and urban sketchers — the metal box plus velvet bag is heavier than pocket sets like the Cotman Sketchers’ set
- Paint Colors:168
- Brushes:8 synthetic squirrel hair brushes
- Watercolor Paper:25 sheets, cold-pressed
- Water Brush Pens:6
- Accessories:Palette, swatch sheet, sponges, marker, pencil, eraser, sharpener, tape
- Storage:Lockable metal box with velvet bag
- Model Number:BD062
Our verdict“This set makes the most sense for someone who wants a full mobile studio in a single purchase rather than assembling paper, brushes, and paints separately.”
Winsor & Newton Cotman Watercolor Paint Set, 20 Colors, 5ml Tubes
Compared with the massive 100-plus-color sets elsewhere in this roundup, the Cotman 20-tube set takes the opposite approach — fewer colors, better pigment discipline. Because these are 5ml tubes rather than pre-filled pans, artists learn to mix custom washes and control paint strength from the first session, which builds real skill faster than picking from 168 ready-made pans. Winsor & Newton’s Cotman line is a student-grade formulation with professional-grade habits: high transparency and solid lightfastness, and the colors adhere to paper, glass, and wood. The catch is capacity and reach — 5ml tubes run dry quickly under heavy use, and a few pigments lack the saturation of the company’s Professional line, so dedicated artists will outgrow this set.
Pros:- Tube format teaches mixing and paint control better than fixed pans
- High transparency and reliable lightfastness for a student-grade price
- Works on paper, glass, and wood for mixed-media projects
- Reputable brand formulation with consistent quality between tubes
Cons:- Only 20 colors — expansion requires additional sets or single tubes
- 5ml tubes deplete quickly with regular painting
- Some pigments fall short of professional-grade saturation
Best for: New watercolorists who want to learn color mixing with quality student-grade tube paints rather than pre-arranged pans
Not ideal for: Artists wanting maximum color variety or heavy daily output — 20 small tubes won’t sustain either
- Brand:Winsor & Newton
- Paint Type:Watercolor
- Number of Colors:20
- Tube Size:5ml
- Weight:4.32 ounces
- Drying Time:24 hours full cure
- Model Number:0390665
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for beginners who value learning to mix over having every color ready-made, and who want paint quality that won’t hold them back as they improve.”
Artecho 168-Color Watercolor Paint Set with Metallics
Where the Smallbudi 168-color set spreads its budget across tools and paper, the Artecho 168 puts everything into pigment variety — including metallic, pastel, and fluorescent shades that most sets in this roundup simply don’t offer. Those specialty colors matter for specific work: hand-lettering, card-making, illustration accents, and journal spreads that need shimmer or pop. The kit still covers basics with water brush pens, a sketching pencil, a watercolor pad, and a sponge, all secured in a sturdy metal case, and the ASTM D-4236 certified, acid-free formulation is safe for younger artists. The tradeoff mirrors the Smallbudi’s: fewer classic mixing pigments than the color count suggests, since a chunk of the palette is specialty effects, and the full case is heavy for casual travel compared with the Cotman Sketchers’ Pocket Set.
Pros:- Metallic, pastel, and fluorescent shades rarely found in standard sets
- Complete tool bundle including water brush pens, pad, and sketching supplies
- Non-toxic, acid-free, ASTM D-4236 certified for safe use
- Well-organized metal case keeps 168 pans accessible
Cons:- Specialty-heavy palette means fewer classic mixing colors than the 168 count implies
- Case is bulky for light or frequent travel
- Overwhelming color selection for complete beginners
Best for: Lettering artists, journalers, and craft-focused painters who need metallic and fluorescent accents alongside standard colors
Not ideal for: Traditional fine-art painters focused on subtle mixing — a large share of the palette is specialty effects rather than core pigments
- Number of Colors:168
- Color Types:Classic, Metallic, Pastel, Fluorescent
- Includes:Water brush pens, sketching pencil, eraser, sharpener, color chart, watercolor pad, sponge
- Safety Standards:ASTM D-4236
- Material:Non-toxic, acid-free
- Storage:Portable metal tin case
Our verdict“This is the set for craft and lettering work that demands shimmer and neon accents; painters who mainly need a refined classic palette should look at smaller artist-grade sets instead.”
How We Picked
My ranking logic starts with pigment quality and paint behavior, because that’s what separates a set an artist will outgrow from one they’ll keep using. I looked at how each paint rewets, whether colors lift and mix cleanly, and how much the pigment load holds up when diluted into washes — the place where budget sets most often fall apart. Lightfastness claims were weighed seriously for sets marketed toward professionals, since a painting that fades in two years isn’t a bargain at any price.
From there, I scored each set on format and portability (pocket sets versus tubes versus boxed kits), color range and curation (whether 100+ colors actually add mixing value or just padding), build quality of the case and pans, and value per useful color. Sets that concentrated quality into fewer colors ranked above sets that maximized count, and kits whose included brushes and palettes were genuinely usable scored higher than bundles that padded their specs with throwaway accessories. The result is a lineup ordered by who each set best serves, not by price or color count alone.
| watercolor paint sets for artist | Safety Standards |
|---|---|
| Artistro Professional Watercol | — |
| ARTISTRO Deluxe Watercolor Pai | ASTM D-4236, EN71 |
| Nicpro Watercolor Paint Set fo | ASTM D4236, EN71 |
| Winsor & Newton Cotman Waterco | — |
| Caliart 128 Colors Watercolor | ASTM D-4236 |
| Watercolor Paint Set with 100 | ASTM D-4236, EN71 |
| Kuretake Gansai Tambi Watercol | — |
| ARTISTRO Watercolor Paint Set | ASTM D-4236, EN71 |
| Artecho 48 Colors Watercolor P | — |
| Artecho 100 Colors Watercolor | ASTM D-4236 |
| Smallbudi All-in-One Watercolo | — |
| Winsor & Newton Cotman Waterco | — |
| Artecho 168-Color Watercolor P | ASTM D-4236 |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Watercolor Paint Sets For Artists
Before picking a set by color count alone, it helps to understand what actually drives performance and long-term satisfaction with watercolor. These are the factors that shaped my rankings — and the ones most buyers get wrong.Pigment Load Matters More Than Color Count
The single most common mistake is equating a bigger box with a better set. A 168-color set with a thin, filler-heavy formula will produce washed-out, chalky paintings, while a well-made 24-color set with dense pigment can mix nearly any hue you need with more vibrancy. Professional watercolor is built around mixing from a curated palette, not reaching for a pre-matched pan — that’s why serious sets keep color counts modest and invest in pigment concentration. Before buying, look for signs of quality: artist-grade labeling, single-pigment colors, and stated lightfastness ratings. If a listing brags about color count but says nothing about pigment, that silence usually tells you where the budget went. Buy the count you’ll actually use, and put the savings toward paint that performs.
Pans, Tubes, or Half-Pans: Match Format to Workflow
Watercolor comes in three practical formats, and choosing wrong guarantees friction. Tubes suit studio painters who premix washes and work large — you can squeeze exactly what you need and control consistency. Full and half pans suit sketchers, plein air painters, and anyone who paints small; they’re instantly ready with a wet brush and travel without spilling. Pocket-sized pan sets trade capacity for portability, which is why they dominate field kits. A useful rule: if you mostly paint at a desk, tubes or a tube-fed palette give you more control; if you paint anywhere else, pans win. Some artists eventually run both — tubes for studio work, a small pan set for travel — and that split often costs less than one oversized all-in-one kit.
Lightfastness: The Spec Hobbyists Ignore and Artists Can’t
Lightfastness measures how well a pigment resists fading under light exposure, and it’s the difference between a painting that lasts decades and one that dulls within a couple of years. Budget and mid-range sets rarely publish lightfastness ratings for every color, which itself is informative — professional lines like Winsor & Newton’s artist grade disclose it per pigment. If you’re selling work, framing it, or gifting anything you care about, prioritize sets with stated lightfastness and avoid heavily fluorescent, metallic, or pearlescent colors for permanent pieces, as those fade fastest. Practicing sketches and studies don’t need this protection, which is why student-grade sets remain a smart buy for skill-building. The mistake to avoid is assuming all colors in a set age equally — reds, pinks, and violets are typically the first to go.
Bundled Accessories: Value or Filler?
Many sets in this price range pad their appeal with brushes, palettes, water brushes, and sketchbooks. Evaluate these honestly: bundled brushes are almost always synthetic, low-spring, and soft enough that they frustrate anyone past the beginner stage. That doesn’t make bundles bad — a true beginner with zero supplies gets genuine value from a complete kit — but it means the paint should carry the purchase decision, not the extras. A reasonable rule is to mentally subtract the accessories and ask whether the paint alone justifies the price. If it does, the bundle is a bonus; if it doesn’t, you’re paying for landfill. Plan on adding one decent round brush within your first few months regardless of which set you choose.
Student Grade versus Artist Grade: When to Pay More
Student-grade paints (like Winsor & Newton’s Cotman line) use cheaper pigments or more filler to hit accessible prices, while artist-grade paints use higher pigment concentrations and more permanent pigments. The gap shows up in two places: saturation at full dilution, and mixing behavior — student paints can turn muddy faster when you blend three or more colors. For your first year of painting, student grade is the right call, because technique matters far more than paint at that stage. Upgrade to artist grade when you notice your washes looking weak despite good technique, or when you start producing work you want to keep or sell. Japanese watercolors like Kuretake’s Gansai Tambi occupy a useful middle ground, offering unusually rich pigment at student prices, which is part of why they rank highly here.
Portability and Case Design
A set’s case determines whether it actually leaves the house. Look for securely seated pans (loose pans rattle, crack, and mix colors into each other in a bag), a functional mixing surface built into the lid, and a compact footprint that fits your bag or pocket. Pocket sets with fold-out palettes are the gold standard for urban sketching, while large boxed kits are genuinely studio-bound despite ‘portable’ marketing language. Water brushes paired with pan sets create the lightest possible travel kit — no water container needed. One underrated factor: how easily pans can be replaced or reordered individually. Quality brands sell replacement pans, so a good case becomes a long-term palette system rather than a disposable box.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a 100-plus color set better than a 24 color set for learning watercolor?
Usually the opposite. Learning watercolor is largely about learning to mix, and a smaller curated palette forces exactly that skill. With 24 well-chosen colors you learn color relationships, mixing limits, and how to hit a target hue twice — abilities a 168-color box lets you sidestep. Big sets also create decision fatigue, which quietly stalls progress for beginners. The strong case for a large set is convenience for casual hobby painting, journaling, or if you simply enjoy swatching and exploring color for its own sake. If your goal is developing as an artist, start with 24 or fewer colors and add tubes individually as you discover gaps in your palette.
Should I buy pans or tubes if I’m just starting out?
Pans make the smoother entry point for most beginners because setup is instant — wet the brush and paint — and there’s no waste or storage puzzle for opened paint. Tubes are better if you already know you like working large, since tube paint mixes into big, even washes more easily than paint lifted from a pan. Tubes also let you refill a pan palette, which is how many artists eventually combine both formats. The practical downside of tubes for newcomers is drying them out or using far more than needed. If you’re unsure, start with a modest pan set and add a few tubes of the colors you burn through fastest.
Do metallic and pearlescent watercolors justify the higher price on bigger sets?
They add genuine sparkle for cards, lettering, and illustrative accents, but they shouldn’t drive your purchase. Metallic pigments sit on the paper surface rather than absorbing into it, which means they can rub, flake, and behave inconsistently under glazes. They also rank among the least lightfast colors in any set, so they’re a poor choice for framed or sold work. Where they earn their keep is decorative projects, hand-lettering, and adding highlights on studies. A reasonable approach: buy a core set of standard colors first, then add a small dedicated metallic pan set later if that style appeals to you, rather than letting metallics inflate the count on your main palette.
How long do watercolor pans last, and do they expire?
Watercolor doesn’t spoil in the way food does — a well-made pan can last a decade or more if kept dry and reasonably clean. The real risks are contamination (colors migrating into neighbors via a dirty brush), mold from storing damp pans in a sealed case, and cracking as binders age in very cheap paints. Quality honey- or gum-based paints can develop a slightly sticky or hard surface but still reconstitute with water and patient wetting. Practical habits extend life dramatically: let pans dry before closing the case, use separate rinse water, and wipe the mixing lid clean after sessions. If a pan smells sour or grows visible mold, that one’s done — but the rest of the set is usually fine.
Can I realistically sell paintings made with student-grade sets like Cotman or Caliart?
Yes, with one condition: check the lightfastness of the specific colors you use, because that’s what protects the buyer, not the brand name. Cotman, as a reputable student line, publishes per-color ratings, so you can simply build sellable work around its more permanent pigments and reserve the fugitive colors for studies. Budget sets that publish no lightfastness data are riskier, since you can’t know which hues will fade — a real problem if a collector hangs the piece near a window. Many professional artists sell early work painted in student grade without issue by choosing stable pigments like earth tones and most blues. Once sales become regular, migrating your core palette to artist grade protects your reputation and improves saturation at the same time.
Conclusion
The right pick here depends less on price and more on how you paint. For best overall, the Kuretake Gansai Tambi 24 Colors delivers the richest, most artist-grade paint behavior in the lineup and leaves room to grow. For best value, the Winsor & Newton Cotman 20-color tube set gives you a trusted brand’s mixing-friendly paint at a student price, while the Cotman Pocket Set takes the value crown for travel. For beginners, the Nicpro 36-color set offers a gentle entry point with usable accessories, and the Artistro Professional 48 with XL pans is the step-up once basic technique clicks. For hobbyists and color enthusiasts, the Caliart 128 or Smallbudi 168 kits maximize variety and convenience — just go in knowing the paint is built for fun, not permanence. Studio painters working large should lean toward tubes, urban sketchers toward pockets, and anyone producing saleable work toward sets with published lightfastness. Whatever you choose, a modest curated palette you actually master will outpaint a giant box you merely admire.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
