Choosing art supplies for mixed media is less about finding one perfect kit than deciding how much control you want over what goes into your materials collection. A premade mixed media set groups common tools and media in one purchase, which can make starting a project simple. Curating supplies individually takes more research but lets you select each item for your surface, techniques, and budget.
Get art and craft supplies delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook, 9 x 12 in, 60 Sheets, 98 lb/160 gsm
- ✔ Brand: MOFUNY
- ✔ Page size: 9 × 12 inches
- ✔ Sheets: 60
Mixed Media Sketchbook, 9 x 12 Inches, 30 Sheets
- ✔ Page size: 9 × 12 inches
- ✔ Sheets: 30
- ✔ Paper weight: 98 lb / 160 gsm
Prang Mixed Media Journal
- ✔ Page size: 8.5 × 11 inches
- ✔ Binding: Spiral-bound
- ✔ Back cover: Heavy chipboard
The real tradeoff is convenience against fit. A set may cost less upfront and help a beginner experiment across several media, but its paper, paints, or tools may not suit every technique. Individual supplies can deliver better performance where it matters, though buying everything at once can cost more and leave you with a less coordinated collection. Choose a set for easy exploration; choose individual materials when you already know what you use or need specific performance.
At a Glance
| Criteria | Premade mixed media art supply set | Curated individual mixed media supplies | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Often lower than purchasing a similar number of items separately, though value depends on what is included. | Can be higher at first, but spending can be phased and focused on essentials. | A |
| Convenience | One purchase provides a ready-made selection, often with basic tools and media. | Requires choosing products and checking compatibility before buying. | A |
| Material quality control | Quality is set by the kit; some components may be better than others. | Full control over brands, grades, sizes, and archival or specialty properties. | B |
| Technique flexibility | Useful for trying several compatible media, but selection and quantities are fixed. | Can be tailored to specific processes, surfaces, and preferred media. | B |
| Waste and unused items | A fixed assortment can include colors, tools, or formats the artist never uses. | Lower risk of unwanted extras when purchases follow a real project plan. | B |
| Restocking and long-term value | Convenient to start, but replacing a weak or depleted component may mean buying separately anyway. | Easy to replenish favorite items; investment can grow with skill and practice. | B |
| Suitability for beginners | Strong for low-pressure exploration, especially when the set identifies compatible materials. | Good for focused learners, though product choices can overwhelm someone starting from scratch. | A |
MOFUNY Mixed Media Sketchbook, 9 x 12 in, 60 Sheets, 98 lb/160 gsm
For buyers who want one sketchbook to cover drawing and painting experiments, MOFUNY has the most balanced specification set here. Its 9 × 12-inch pages provide room for layered compositions, and its 60 sheets of 98 lb (160 gsm) acid-free paper offer twice the stated page count of the other 9 × 12-inch option. The product description names pencil, pen, charcoal, watercolor, acrylic, and gouache, making it the broadest explicitly described media range in this lineup.The ring binding is more than a construction detail: the book is designed to open flat and rotate 360 degrees, which can help when we want to work across the page, fold the cover back, or keep a sketchbook manageable on a smaller surface. Compared with the micro-perforated 30-sheet book, MOFUNY favors more pages and flexible handling over easy page removal. Compared with Prang, it gives buyers clearer paper-weight and media information, but it is larger and less oriented toward compact journal use.There are limits to what the description establishes. It says the paper is designed to resist ink bleed-through and color fading, but provides no independent performance evidence or detailed guidance for heavy watercolor applications. Buyers planning repeated wet layers should not infer that 160 gsm paper behaves like dedicated watercolor stock. Still, for a mixed-media artist seeking a larger working area and a substantial supply of pages, MOFUNY is the strongest all-round fit.
Pros:
- 60 sheets provide more working pages than either alternative.
- 98 lb (160 gsm), acid-free paper is specified for a wide range of media.
- Ring binding opens flat and rotates 360 degrees.
- Hard covers help protect the pages.
Cons:
- The product description does not establish how the paper handles repeated heavy wet layers.
- The 9 × 12-inch format is less compact than the Prang journal.
- Pages are not described as micro-perforated or designed for clean removal.
Best for: Artists who want a large, 9 × 12-inch sketchbook with a higher stated page count and a broad range of named dry and wet media.
Not ideal for: Artists who need cleanly removable pages or plan demanding watercolor techniques and want a paper specification verified for that use.
Bottom line: We recommend MOFUNY first for its combination of generous page count, stated paper weight, and flexible binding, while keeping heavy-watercolor expectations realistic.
“We recommend MOFUNY first for its combination of generous page count, stated paper weight, and flexible binding, while keeping heavy-watercolor expectations realistic.”
Mixed Media Sketchbook, 9 x 12 Inches, 30 Sheets
This 9 × 12-inch sketchbook is the better match when we want to take work out of the book without cutting along an ordinary bound edge. Its micro-perforated pages are intended to tear away cleanly, making this the clearest choice for sharing studies, handing in assignments, or displaying selected pieces. Like MOFUNY, it lists 98 lb (160 gsm) acid-free paper and spiral binding that lets it lie flat, but it supplies 30 sheets rather than 60.That page-removal feature gives it a distinct role rather than making it a smaller version of our top pick. MOFUNY emphasizes page supply and a 360-degree rotating ring binding; this book emphasizes a tidy way to separate finished work. Its lightly textured surface is described for pencils, pens, crayons, pastels, and acrylics, with watercolor limited to light washes. That qualification makes the recommendation more useful: buyers can plan modest washes, but should look elsewhere or confirm suitability if their work involves saturated washes or multiple wet layers.The paper is described as thick and designed to resist bleed-through, but we should not treat that wording as a guarantee for every ink or paint. Nor does the product description give a detailed comparison of its wet strength to MOFUNY. If keeping every page bound is more important than removing artwork, the higher-capacity MOFUNY is the more practical choice. If clean tear-out and a clear light-wash boundary matter most, this book’s perforated layout is its deciding advantage.
Pros:
- Micro-perforated pages are designed to tear out cleanly.
- 98 lb (160 gsm) acid-free paper is specified.
- Spiral binding allows the book to lie flat.
- Light texture supports several dry media and acrylics.
Cons:
- The 30-sheet count is half that of the MOFUNY sketchbook.
- Watercolor use is specified for light washes only.
- The description does not establish performance with heavy wet layering.
Best for: Students and artists who work at 9 × 12 inches and want to remove selected drawings or paintings neatly.
Not ideal for: Artists who need a high page count or intend to use substantial watercolor washes and layered wet techniques.
Bottom line: Choose this book over MOFUNY when removable pages matter more than getting twice as many sheets.
“Choose this book over MOFUNY when removable pages matter more than getting twice as many sheets.”
Prang Mixed Media Journal
Prang is the simplest fit for someone who wants a mixed-media journal primarily for sketching, drawing, and painting on the go. At 8.5 × 11 inches, it is slightly smaller than both 9 × 12-inch alternatives, a modest size difference that can make carrying and handling the book easier. Its heavy chipboard backing also gives the journal a firmer support for drawing when a desk or drawing board is not available.That practical, journal-like character separates it from MOFUNY’s higher-capacity format and the 30-sheet book’s tear-away pages. Prang is spiral-bound and its paper is acid-free, but the supplied details do not state a paper weight, sheet count, or a specific limit for wet media. As a result, MOFUNY and the 30-sheet sketchbook are easier to recommend when we need to compare paper capacity or plan around a stated 98 lb (160 gsm) sheet. Prang’s media description is broad, but it does not name particular techniques such as light watercolor washes.We would choose it for portable drawing and general painting rather than for a project where paper weight and wet-layer tolerance are critical buying criteria. Its recyclable paper is a useful material detail, though it does not resolve the missing performance information. If we need a clearly specified surface for mixed dry and wet experiments, MOFUNY is the safer choice on the information provided; if we want a compact journal with a supportive back, Prang has the more focused everyday role.
Pros:
- 8.5 × 11-inch format is slightly smaller than the other two books.
- Heavy chipboard backing provides a firm drawing support.
- Acid-free paper is described for sketching, drawing, and painting.
- Paper is identified as recyclable.
Cons:
- Paper weight and sheet count are not specified in the supplied details.
- Wet-media limits and watercolor suitability are not clarified.
- It does not offer the stated 360-degree rotation of MOFUNY or the tear-away pages of the other sketchbook.
Best for: Artists and students seeking a slightly smaller spiral journal for sketching and drawing, including work away from a firm table.
Not ideal for: Mixed-media painters who need a stated paper weight, a known page count, or clear guidance for watercolor and other wet applications.
Bottom line: Prang is the most portable-feeling journal choice, but we would favor a better-specified paper option for wet-media-heavy work.
“Prang is the most portable-feeling journal choice, but we would favor a better-specified paper option for wet-media-heavy work.”
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Key Differences
The biggest practical difference is who makes the selection. With a premade set, the maker has already chosen the mix and quantities, so you can begin experimenting without comparing every product. That is valuable when you have not yet learned whether you prefer collage, drawing, wet media, or layered combinations. The compromise is that a kit is a package deal: a weak paper pad or an unsuitable brush can limit results even when other contents are useful.
Buying individual supplies reverses that tradeoff. You can match paper weight and surface to wet or dry media, choose pigments you will actually use, and avoid tools that do not fit your process. It can cost more at checkout, but the expense is easier to direct and spread over time. For artists with a defined practice, this usually means better long-term value. For someone exploring, the research and choices may outweigh those gains, making a sensible starter set the more practical first buy.
Detailed Comparison
Upfront cost (Premade mixed media art supply set wins — moderate)
A premade set usually wins on initial outlay because several items are bundled, and the artist can start with one purchase. The advantage is moderate rather than guaranteed: kits vary, and a large set may contain inexpensive components or extras that do not add useful value. Individual supplies can have a higher initial total, especially when buying multiple media and tools at once. But a curated approach can also start small—one suitable surface, a few colors, and a basic adhesive—and expand later. Choose A when a fixed starter budget needs to cover a broad range right away; choose B when you can buy in stages and prioritize quality.
Convenience (Premade mixed media art supply set wins — major)
The premade set is the clear winner, with a major difference for people who want to begin quickly. Its contents are selected and packaged together, which cuts down on product research and shopping. Some sets also include a suggested project or basic guidance. Individual buying involves comparing sizes, material properties, and compatibility, then locating products from several sources. That extra effort may pay off in a better-matched collection, but it is real work. If choosing art supplies feels like a barrier, start with a suitable set; if product research is part of the process you enjoy, the inconvenience of B is limited.
Material quality control (Curated individual mixed media supplies wins — major)
Individual purchases win by a major margin when performance matters. You can select a surface that handles the amount of water you use, choose paints with the properties you need, and spend more on the tools that affect your results most. A kit fixes those choices for you, and quality can be uneven: a set may pair useful drawing media with paper that buckles under wet layers. Not every project needs professional-grade materials, however. A beginner testing ideas may be well served by adequate supplies. Choose B for demanding work or known preferences; choose A when experimentation matters more than consistent high-end performance.
Technique flexibility (Curated individual mixed media supplies wins — moderate)
Curated supplies win by a moderate margin because they can be built around a particular way of working. An artist layering watercolor, ink, and collage can select an appropriate surface and adhesives rather than relying on a kit’s general-purpose choices. A premade set can still be useful for trying different media, and its coordinated range may encourage experimentation. Its limits are the fixed selection, colors, formats, and amounts. If you want broad, low-stakes sampling, A can be more inviting; if you need materials to support specific combinations or a repeatable process, B is the stronger choice.
Waste and unused items (Curated individual mixed media supplies wins — moderate)
Buying individually is generally better for reducing unused supplies, a moderate advantage when you already know your habits. You can purchase only the colors, tools, and sizes needed for planned work. A kit’s fixed mix may include duplicates or materials that do not suit your style, leaving part of the purchase untouched. For a new artist, though, trying unfamiliar items is not automatically waste: discovering a preferred medium has value. The better option depends on whether exploration is the goal. Choose A to sample broadly; choose B to keep a focused studio lean.
Restocking and long-term value (Curated individual mixed media supplies wins — moderate)
Individual supplies usually provide better long-term value, with a moderate advantage for artists who work regularly. You can replace a favorite pen, adhesive, or paint as it runs out, and gradually upgrade only the pieces that affect your results. A set can offer useful savings at the beginning, but it may not include the preferred product or quantities for repeat work. Once its supplies are used, you may still need to identify and buy replacements separately. A kit makes sense as a first purchase or occasional-use option; B is more economical over time when the artist knows what earns a place in the studio.
Suitability for beginners (Premade mixed media art supply set wins — moderate)
A premade set is the easier fit for many beginners, with a moderate advantage when the goal is to start without building a product list from scratch. A thoughtfully chosen kit provides a manageable range and reduces the risk of overlooking basic tools. It is not automatically beginner-friendly: some kits include low-quality materials, unclear instructions, or more items than a learner needs. Individual buying suits a beginner who has a specific project, a teacher’s list, or a strong interest in learning material properties. Otherwise, begin with a modest set, then replace or add items based on what you actually use.
Premade mixed media art supply set: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Simple one-purchase starting point for trying several media.
- Usually lower upfront cost than assembling a broad collection separately.
- Can reduce product research and help new artists begin sooner.
- A coordinated assortment may encourage experimentation.
Cons:
- Fixed contents may include unwanted or duplicate items.
- Quality can vary across components, particularly paper and tools.
- Limited control over sizes, quantities, brands, and material properties.
- Replacing favored items later requires separate shopping.
Curated individual mixed media supplies: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Complete control over quality, format, and suitability for a project.
- Purchases can focus on frequently used materials and avoid unnecessary extras.
- Easy to restock exact favorites and upgrade selectively.
- Works well for specialized techniques and established preferences.
Cons:
- Requires research and product-by-product decisions.
- A broad collection can cost more at the outset.
- Compatibility mistakes are possible without material knowledge.
- A beginner may feel overwhelmed by the number of choices.
Who Should Choose What
Choose Premade mixed media art supply set if:
- You are new to mixed media and want to test several materials before settling on a style.
- You need a convenient starter collection within a limited upfront budget.
- You prefer a ready-made selection to researching each supply.
- You make art occasionally and do not need consistent quantities of specific materials.
Choose Curated individual mixed media supplies if:
- You already know which media and techniques you use most.
- Your projects need a particular paper surface, paint property, tool size, or adhesive.
- You want to avoid unused kit contents and restock exact favorites.
- You are willing to spend more initially—or buy gradually—for better control and repeatable results.
Skip both if: Neither approach fits if you have a specific class or project list that names required materials; follow that list first rather than buying a broad kit or substituting without checking compatibility.
Value for Money
A premade set is worth paying for when convenience and variety solve a real problem: you are new, want to try several media, and would otherwise delay starting while comparing products. Judge the bundle by useful contents, not item count. A large box is poor value if its paper cannot handle your planned layers or many tools will sit unused.
Individual supplies are usually the better value once your preferences become clear. You can direct more of your budget toward the surface or media that matter and avoid repeatedly replacing components that fall short. You do not have to buy a complete collection at once; add essentials as projects require them. Pay the extra upfront only if the control or performance will improve work you expect to make regularly. For casual exploration, a carefully selected basic set is the more sensible spend.
Final Verdict
For most first-time mixed media artists, choose a premade set that contains genuinely useful basics and a surface suited to the media you want to try. It lowers the effort and cost of getting started, and its limitations matter less while you are still discovering your preferences. Do not choose solely by how many items are in the box.
Choose individual supplies if you have a defined technique, need dependable results, or already know which materials you reach for. The deciding factor is how much control you need: the set wins on convenience and initial affordability, while curated supplies win on quality choice, fit, and ongoing value. Once you know your working style, buying selectively is the stronger long-term approach.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a premade mixed media set good for a beginner?
Often, yes. It offers a convenient way to try several materials without researching every item. Check that the surface suits the media you plan to use and that the set contains supplies you will actually try; a high item count alone does not make a kit useful.
Is it cheaper to buy a mixed media set or supplies separately?
A set often costs less upfront than buying a comparable range individually. Separate purchases can be better value over time if they focus on materials you use regularly and avoid unwanted extras. Compare the useful contents, not just the sticker price.
Can I mix supplies from different brands?
Usually, yes. Mixed media work often combines products from different makers. Match each material to the surface and technique, and check product instructions when compatibility matters, such as when layering wet media or using an adhesive over a particular finish.
When should I move from a kit to individual supplies?
Switch to buying individually when you can name the materials you use most, when a kit component limits your results, or when you need a specific format or quality. Replace only the items that matter first; you do not need to rebuild your entire collection at once.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
